Often times, the experience of listening to an album for the first time can dictate how you feel about it. In the time of records, and even still with CDs, part of the thrill was putting an album on for that first time while going through the album artwork and liner notes in a painstaking manner, searching for clues or hints as to what the lyrics could mean. My experience with John Mayer’s Continuum is similar, though perhaps a bit adapted for the digital age.

John Mayer, Pittsburgh, PA, August 2008 (Photo Credit: J.W. Johnson Jr.)
In the fall of 2006, change was all around me. For the first time, I was living in my own apartment and was in charge of doing everything for myself for the first time. Though I had been at college for a year at this point, the idea of having nobody to answer to was new and exciting. At the same time, however, I was in an incredibly complicated relationship that deep down I knew wasn’t going anywhere; still yet, I forced the issue out of fear of loneliness. This was a new stage in my life, and I wasn’t sure how to go at it alone.
The day before the album hit stores, I remember a particularly angry phone exchange regarding said relationship, ending with the uncertainty of whether or not there would even be a relationship to worry about the next morning. I suppressed my confused feelings with the promise that at midnight, I would be able to sit and listen to Continuum in peace. As the clock struck midnight, I frantically refreshed my iTunes, hoping that the next mouse click would give me my fix.
I should clarify that until this point, though I was a pretty big Mayer fan, I had very low expectations for the album. His previous albums, though great, took some time to get used to, to dissect and search for meaning, and the only new song that I had heard was “Waiting on the World To Change”, which seemed to be just another basic Mayer song. This time, however, I was set on sitting with the album until I figured it all out, no matter how long it took.
As I sat in my bedroom, illuminated only by the string of Christmas lights that adorned the walls (I thought that’s what you did in college), I began to listen to the album that would come to define the next few months of my life. From start to finish, Continuum is the perfect explanation of love gone wrong. Songs like “I Don’t Trust Myself (With Loving You)” perfectly summed up the hesitation one gets when in new relationship and the idea of letting go of one’s inhibitions, while the slow jam blues of “Gravity” shows the pain of needing someone you know isn’t right for you. Other songs, like “The Heart of Life” crushed me in a way that was both sad and uplifting, with its talk of a “silver lining” and the fear of being in an unfamiliar situation.
The rest of the disc’s tracks seemed to speak to me and my situation in a way that only a few albums had before. There would be no repeated listens necessary to find the meaning in this one; as the album played on, I needed no liner notes to tell me what the lyrics meant. Everything I needed to know about this album I already knew. Mayer had defined, to perfection, what it was like to be scared and vulnerable and unsure of yourself. He even summed up my feelings about things I hadn’t thought much about before, like my parents and getting older (“Stop This Train”) and the necessary evils of war, both literally and as a metaphor for relationships (“Belief”). The song that hit me hardest, however, was “Slow Dancing In A Burning Room”, which described the failure of a relationship between two people who were not right for each other and their realization that no matter what they do, their relationship is essentially over already. I didn’t know it at the time, but this song would come to define the next few months of my life as my relationship disintegrated and I began to question whether it was worth the effort I was putting in.
I listened to Continuum on repeat for the next four hours, and then for the next three months. Something about how painfully beautiful it was, both lyrically and sonically wouldn’t let me press the stop button. And, as dark as the content may have been, there was some hope mixed in. After the end of the messy relationship, songs like Mayer’s cover of the Jimi Hendrix classic “Bold As Love” gave me reassurance that it wasn’t the end of the world, or that “my yellow, in this case, was not so mellow”, if you will. Nothing was as bad as it originally seemed, and this album made me realize that. I came to understand that the past few months was something that everyone goes through, which is how Mayer described “my” situation so well. I was “In Repair”, and it was going to be alright.
Listening to this album now reminds me that good songwriting is something that not just anybody can do. Though the content is relatable to just about everyone, we often cannot come up with a way to describe our feelings. I knew in my gut the way that I really felt, but it would have been impossible for me to spell it out in the way that Mayer did. Thanks to this album, I’ll always have a way to remember that particular part of my life forever, for better or worse.
